Johnny Got His Gun

Johnny Got His Gun

Book - 1970
Average Rating:
11
1
Rate this:
Publisher: New York, L. Stuart [1970, c1959]
Branch Call Number: TRUM
Characteristics: 309 p. 21 cm.

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment

l
lbottge
Apr 23, 2017

5 stars

I read this book in the 70s. Was surprised to learn he had written it after WWI and voluntarily removed it from publication during WWII. Republished in response to the Vietnam War. Movie was made in 1971. Trumbo wrote the screenplay and directed the movie. Having read the book, I remember while watching it (starkly black & white), I was powerfully affected. Called my friend afterwards, asking her if she could hear me. Refusing to testify before the House un-American Activities Committee in 1947, he was blacklisted from the motion picture industry.

l
ltlangham
Apr 22, 2017

Easily the most depressing book I've read to-date. The perspective might've been difficult to get used to at first, but I was quickly able to get past that. As this book centers around Joe Bonham, or "Average Joe", who loses all four of his limbs, most of his head (Described as half of a head in the book), and all of his senses except for feel. His thoughts drive the story, and it paints a whole new picture on the costs of war and what liberty in the U.S. actually entails. It describes it all in completely honest detail. I haven't seen the movie yet, but I highly doubt it will be as good as the book.

I'll never be able to look at the military or injuries the same way again.

k
kaylalgreen
Apr 03, 2017

Johnny Got His Gun is a historical fiction story about Joe Bonham, wounded soldier who was blown nearly to smithereens by a landmine during World War I. He has lost both of his legs, both of his arms, his ears, and his entire face and still managed to survive, with nothing but his own mind to keep him company.

I want to say that I absolutely loved this book, but "love" is such a weird word to use in this situation because this novel is horrifying. I can't love the casualties of war. I can't love the situation that Joe is in. I can't love that only a few years after this book was written and published, World War II happened. I can't love the awful that is war.

The one thing I can love is Dalton Trumbo's phenomenal writing throughout this entire novel and his ability to make you feel all the feels for Joe Bonham. I can also love his ability to make you either question how you feel about war or confirm what you already felt about it. I have read that people became pacifist's after reading this novel, so I'm not the only one that thinks it's powerful as heck. The way Trumbo wrote this book is very interesting. He used a third-person narrative combined with a "stream of consciousness" style of writing. This is a cool combination because even though we spend the entire novel inside Joe's head, Joe never refers to himself as "I" - it's always "he". Perhaps this was done to make it even more obvious that Joe has no control over anything in his current situation because "I" is a lot more controlling than "he". If so, that is genius writing. The novel has long sentences, lots of repetition of certain words/phrases, and lack of punctuation to mimic real thoughts in a person's head, especially under moments of stress, anxiety, sheer joy, and happiness. For some people, these reasons may mean that they have a hard time reading this novel, though I would urge to please appreciate it for what it is as it is the best choice for this story. Personally, I loved the writing style and I don't think this novel would have had the same impact if it was written any other way.

If you think Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse-Five is an amazing anti-war novel and you haven't read this one, you probably should. This book affected me way more than SF did. There were quite a few times where I had to stop reading, close the book and just sit there absorbing what I just read. You experience present Joe with his tasks of trying to figure out how to track time and communicate with his nurse, as well as his incredibly deep thoughts and reflections about the war and what has happened to him. You also experience his flashbacks to his life before the war. This book had it all. I am not ashamed to say that I balled my eyes out while reading Chapter 10. That chapter is the most powerful part of any book I have read in my life. In addition, I have "liked" a few of the best quotes from the book that will hopefully show up on this review.

I would rate this book more stars if I could. If it was a 10 star system, it would get 10 stars. I feel like everyone on Earth should read this book; maybe wars wouldn't be a thing anymore if they did...

l
lukasevansherman
Apr 20, 2015

Grim, harrowing anti-war novel about a horribly wounded soldier. Dalton Trumbo was a screenwriter ("Spartacus," "Exodus") who feel victim to the blacklist, although he wrote this novel before all that insanity. He adapted it into a film in the 70s and Metallica used footage from it for the "One" video. This book really caught on during Vietnam and Ron Kovic, author of "Born on the Fourth of July, wrote the introduction.

jennywile Mar 31, 2015

Strange that something so lyrical could be gory and disturbing. It's a testament to the writing that it is also beautiful at the same time as disturbing.

e
ElijahMorgan
Dec 19, 2014

One of the most depressing and beautiful books I have ever read. The writing in this book can be hard to follow at first, and the sudden changes of times in it can be jarring, but it really helps to immerse you in the mind of the main character. You won't want to read this book more than once after you finish it, as there is a true feeling of lost hope from beginning to end. I cried at multiple points reading this, but never wanted to put it down. A real masterpiece.

b
book_nerdd
Feb 06, 2013

I loved this book. It was terrifying and gruesome and I probably will never read it again, but it was amazing. It's pretty hard to follow at first and the point of view changes without warning, but you get used to it. Also, it's pretty dang rare to find a comma in this book, but after a while you find it really shows how a person's train of thought goes along (you get used to it, too).

arrowking Jun 29, 2012

A little classic. Print version of the ballad "Johnny I hardly knew ye``

Library_Dragon Feb 10, 2012

I read this book in high school and I still recall it vividly to this day. One of the best anti-war books I've ever read. Excellent.

f
frethead
Jan 06, 2011

Metallica wrote "One" after watching the movie version of this book; the book is far superior to the movie and I agree that it one of the most moving and disturbing things I've ever read. There is an audio version of this story in the library-to-go which is very well done and absolutely captivating!

This should be mandatory reading for all members of the human race.

View All Comments

Age

Add Age Suitability

b
book_nerdd
Feb 06, 2013

book_nerdd thinks this title is suitable for 14 years and over

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Notices

Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Quotes

Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at MCPL

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top